The Challenges of Tracking Private Equity Ownership
Pinpointing the exact number of nursing homes owned by private equity firms is complicated by their use of intricate ownership structures, such as holding companies, LLCs, and REITs, which obscure the ultimate owners. Regulatory bodies and organizations like the GAO and PESP have noted that current data, including from CMS, lacks the transparency needed for accurate tracking.
Varying Estimates
Estimates of private equity ownership in nursing homes vary:
- GAO Estimate (2023): The GAO estimated that at least 5% of Medicare-enrolled nursing homes in 2022 had private equity owners, acknowledging this was likely an underestimate.
- PESP Estimate (2025): PESP's analysis suggests private equity firms own between 5% and 13% of U.S. nursing homes, with indications that the actual figure could be higher due to efforts to conceal ownership.
Investment Trends
Private equity investment in healthcare saw substantial growth between 2000 and 2018, though some capital has shifted to other healthcare sectors.
Potential Impact on Care Quality
Some research has suggested a link between private equity ownership and reduced quality of care.
- Staffing Concerns: Studies have indicated potential reductions in staffing levels following private equity acquisitions.
- Health Outcomes: Research has explored potential connections between private equity ownership and resident health outcomes.
Comparison of Ownership Models
Different ownership models often have distinct motivations:
| Feature | Private Equity-Owned Facilities | Non-Private Equity For-Profit Facilities | Non-Profit Facilities |
|---|---|---|---|
| Primary Motivation | Often focused on financial return. | Focused on generating profit. | Mission-driven. |
| Staffing Levels | Some studies suggest lower levels. | Variable. | Often higher. |
| Debt Levels | Frequently high. | Varies. | Generally lower. |
| Quality Indicators | Mixed, some studies raise concerns. | Mixed. | Often higher. |
Regulatory Landscape
Challenges in ownership transparency have prompted calls for increased regulatory oversight and proposed new rules. State-level actions are also underway. The aim is to enhance oversight while addressing industry challenges like workforce shortages and funding.
Conclusion
Determining the exact number of private equity-owned nursing homes is difficult due to complex structures, with estimates ranging between 5% and 13%. This ownership model has attracted scrutiny concerning potential impacts on cost-cutting, staffing, and resident care. While private equity can bring capital, its focus on profit can sometimes conflict with providing high-quality long-term care. Moving forward, greater transparency and regulation are seen as important to align ownership incentives with resident well-being. {Link: Private Equity Stakeholder Project https://pestakeholder.org/reports/pe-is-continuing-to-acquire-and-bankrupt-nursing-homes/}