Politically-Aligned Alternatives
For many, the primary alternatives to AARP are politically-aligned organizations that offer similar benefits with a different ideological focus. These groups often position themselves as conservative alternatives to AARP's more liberal-leaning stance on certain issues.
Association of Mature American Citizens (AMAC)
Founded in 2007, AMAC is perhaps the most direct and well-known competitor to AARP. It explicitly markets itself as the "conservative alternative" for seniors over 50. While AMAC offers a suite of member benefits comparable to AARP, including insurance options, travel discounts, and a magazine, its advocacy platform is rooted in conservative principles. AMAC's lobbying efforts focus on issues like reducing government spending and preserving American values.
60 Plus Association
Another prominent conservative group, the 60 Plus Association, was founded in 1992. This organization focuses on promoting smaller government, lower taxes, and free enterprise. While they offer some discounts to members, their primary function is public advocacy. Their key issues include ending the federal estate tax and advocating for free-market solutions for seniors.
American Seniors Association (ASA)
Established in 2005, the American Seniors Association targets individuals aged 50 and over with a conservative-focused platform. Their five foundational issues include rebuilding national values, social security reform, Medicare reform, tax code reform, and controlling government overspending. Like other conservative groups, ASA provides members with access to various discounts on insurance, travel, and health services.
Specialized Nonprofit Competitors
Beyond the politically-aligned groups, AARP also faces competition from numerous non-profits that focus on specific aspects of senior health and wellness rather than providing a broad spectrum of services.
National Council on Aging (NCOA)
For over 70 years, the National Council on Aging (NCOA) has been dedicated to improving the health and economic security of older adults. Unlike AARP, NCOA's focus is less on broad membership benefits and more on direct support through programs and resources. Their website offers practical tools, benefits checkups, and information to help seniors live healthier, financially stable lives. This is a valuable resource for those seeking targeted assistance.
Meals on Wheels America
Addressing senior hunger and isolation, Meals on Wheels America is a powerful nonprofit that serves older adults across the country. While not a direct competitor in the membership-dues sense, it competes for the attention and trust of the senior demographic by offering a vital service focused entirely on one mission. For seniors needing nutritional support and social connection, this organization is a crucial alternative.
Alzheimer's Association
The Alzheimer's Association is a voluntary health organization that provides care and support for individuals with Alzheimer's and related dementias, as well as their caregivers. It also funds research into the disease. Its specialized focus means that for seniors and families dealing with this specific challenge, the Alzheimer's Association offers a depth of resources and support that a general organization cannot match.
Commercial and Niche Service Providers
In addition to membership and advocacy groups, many commercial companies compete directly with AARP's specific product offerings.
-
Insurance Carriers: AARP has a strong partnership with UnitedHealthcare for its Medicare plans. However, numerous other insurance companies, including Humana, Anthem, Blue Cross Blue Shield, and Mutual of Omaha, offer competing Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plans, Medicare Advantage plans, and other health and life insurance products. Seniors are not limited to the AARP/UnitedHealthcare option.
-
Travel and Lifestyle Discounts: Many organizations and services provide discounts that compete with AARP's perks. AAA offers roadside assistance and travel discounts for a fee, while many retailers and restaurants offer their own senior discounts that do not require an AARP membership. Even some Medicare plans include free gym memberships through programs like SilverSneakers.
-
Senior Living and Care Services: Large corporations like Brookdale Senior Living and Life Care Centers of America offer a range of housing and care options. While AARP advocates for policies that support aging in place, these companies offer direct, private-sector alternatives for senior living.
Choosing the Right Fit: A Comparison
To help you decide which organization is right for you, here is a comparison of AARP and its primary alternatives:
| Feature | AARP | AMAC | National Council on Aging (NCOA) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Political Alignment | Non-partisan (per AARP), though often perceived as more liberal | Conservative | Non-partisan; focused on direct services |
| Membership Age | 50+ | 50+ | Focus on older adults |
| Primary Focus | Broad benefits (insurance, discounts, publications) and advocacy | Conservative advocacy and member discounts | Health and financial security for vulnerable seniors |
| Cost | Typically $16/year | Starts at $16/year | No membership fees for most resources |
| Key Benefits | Partnered insurance (UHC), travel/retail discounts, magazine | Insurance access, conservative advocacy, various discounts | Online tools, benefits checkup, fall prevention programs |
| Strength | Large network, significant lobbying power, wide range of benefits | Strong appeal to conservative seniors, competitive benefits | Specialized, targeted support programs, no political focus |
The Landscape of Senior Support
Deciding which organization to join depends on your priorities. If you are looking for a powerful, broad-based organization with a wide range of benefits and are comfortable with its political leanings, AARP may be a good fit. If your views align with conservative principles and you seek similar benefits, AMAC or the 60 Plus Association might be preferable.
For those more interested in highly specific support, non-profits like NCOA offer free, targeted resources that can be incredibly valuable. And for those primarily seeking discounts or insurance, you can often find competitive options directly through commercial providers, many of which offer their own senior-specific deals.
The real benefit is understanding that you have a choice. Investigating these alternatives allows you to select an organization that best reflects your financial, health, and political interests, ensuring your senior years are well-supported on your terms. For information on finding resources related to aging, the federal Eldercare Locator is a great place to start at https://www.eldercare.acl.gov/.
