Skip to content

Is 59 a good retirement age? A financial and lifestyle guide

4 min read

According to a 2024 study, the average retirement age in the U.S. is 62, indicating many consider leaving the workforce before the traditional age. Navigating the complexities to determine if 59 is a good retirement age requires careful financial and personal evaluation.

Quick Summary

Retiring at 59 is a personal decision dependent on a robust financial plan that accounts for early withdrawal penalties, bridging the healthcare coverage gap, and other lifestyle factors. It's achievable for those who prepare meticulously.

Key Points

  • Financial Readiness: Retiring at 59 requires a very strong financial plan to fund the six-year gap before Medicare and potentially the first few years before Social Security.

  • Early Withdrawal Rule: You must wait until age 59½ to withdraw from most tax-advantaged accounts penalty-free, though the 'Rule of 55' may offer an exception for employer plans.

  • Healthcare Gap is Critical: You will need to find and budget for health insurance coverage between ages 59 and 65, which can be a significant expense.

  • Lifestyle and Purpose: A successful early retirement goes beyond finances and requires a plan for how you will spend your time and find purpose outside of a career.

  • Longevity Risk: Withdrawing funds earlier means your nest egg needs to last longer, making a conservative and sustainable withdrawal strategy crucial.

  • Consider All Factors: The right retirement age is deeply personal; it depends on a thorough evaluation of your finances, health, and lifestyle aspirations.

In This Article

The dream of early retirement is appealing, offering years of freedom and new experiences. But for those considering leaving the workforce at 59, the path is filled with unique financial and lifestyle considerations. Moving from active employment to full retirement at this age is a significant step that demands a clear understanding of your financial health, potential challenges, and personal goals.

The Financial Landscape of a 59-Year-Old Retiree

Retiring before the traditional age of 65 or older presents specific financial hurdles. The key to a successful retirement at 59 is not just having a nest egg, but knowing how to access and manage it effectively until other income sources, like Social Security and Medicare, become available.

Accessing Your Retirement Funds

One of the most important milestones is reaching age 59½. At this point, most individuals can begin withdrawing from their IRAs and 401(k)s without incurring the 10% early withdrawal tax penalty. However, retiring at 59 means you are still half a year away from this milestone. This requires a strategy to fund your living expenses for that interim period, such as drawing from taxable investment accounts, cash savings, or a personal pension. It is also important to remember the 'Rule of 55,' which allows for penalty-free withdrawals from a job-related 401(k) if you leave your job in or after the calendar year you turn 55. This rule does not apply to IRAs.

The All-Important Healthcare Puzzle

For most, Medicare doesn't kick in until age 65, leaving a six-year gap for health insurance coverage. This is a critical and potentially costly factor. Your options to bridge this gap include:

  • COBRA coverage: If you lose or leave your job, you may be eligible to continue your health insurance through COBRA, typically for up to 18 months. However, you will likely pay the full premium, which can be very expensive.
  • Marketplace plans: Purchasing a health insurance plan through the Affordable Care Act (ACA) marketplace is another option. Subsidies may be available depending on your income.
  • Spouse's plan: If your spouse is still working and has health coverage through their employer, you may be able to join their plan.

Planning for a Longer Retirement

Retiring at 59 means your savings will need to last longer. A conservative withdrawal strategy is essential. Many financial experts recommend a withdrawal rate of around 4% of your portfolio's value in the first year, adjusting for inflation in subsequent years. This helps minimize the risk of outliving your money, a concern known as longevity risk.

The Lifestyle and Non-Financial Aspects of Retiring at 59

Retirement is more than just a financial transition; it's a profound lifestyle change. Successful early retirement requires emotional and social preparation as well as financial readiness.

Finding Purpose and Staying Active

Many people derive a sense of purpose and identity from their careers. Retiring early means you need to find new ways to stay engaged and fulfilled. Consider exploring new hobbies, volunteering, or starting a passion project. The key is to find activities that keep you mentally and physically active.

Maintaining Social Connections

Socializing with colleagues is a built-in part of many jobs. Leaving the workforce can lead to social isolation if you don't make an effort to cultivate new social circles. Joining clubs, taking classes, or staying connected with friends and family are vital for your overall well-being.

A Comparison of Retirement Strategies

Factor Retiring at 59 Retiring at 67 (Full Retirement Age)
Early Access to Funds Potential 10% penalty on withdrawals from IRAs/401(k)s until 59½; Rule of 55 can apply to employer plans. No early withdrawal penalty on IRAs/401(k)s.
Healthcare Coverage Must fund health insurance for a ~6-year gap until Medicare eligibility (65). Medicare coverage is available at 65.
Social Security Benefits Can start collecting at 62 (reduced benefits) but delaying increases monthly payouts. Full monthly benefits are available.
Longevity Risk Requires a more conservative withdrawal strategy to make savings last longer. Longer career and shorter retirement reduces longevity risk.
Work-Life Balance More years to pursue personal interests, travel, and spend time with family. Less time in retirement, but potentially more financial security.

Your Action Plan for a 59-Year-Old Retirement

  1. Assess Your Financial Health: Get a clear picture of your assets, liabilities, and monthly expenses. A detailed budget is a must.
  2. Model Your Retirement Plan: Use a retirement calculator or work with a financial advisor to project how long your savings will last based on different withdrawal rates and market scenarios.
  3. Plan for the Healthcare Gap: Research ACA marketplace options and factor health insurance premiums into your retirement budget.
  4. Optimize Social Security: Understand how your benefits will be affected by retiring early versus waiting. The decision of when to claim Social Security is a significant one.
  5. Craft a Post-Work Life Plan: Think about what you want to do with your time. A fulfilling retirement requires more than just not working.

For reliable financial guidance, consider consulting an organization like the Financial Planning Association.

Is 59 a good retirement age?

Ultimately, the question isn't whether 59 is a universally 'good' age, but whether it's the right age for you. The answer depends on your personal financial readiness, health, and life goals. By understanding the challenges and creating a thoughtful, comprehensive plan, retiring at 59 can be a rewarding and fulfilling phase of life. Rushing into it without proper preparation, however, can lead to unnecessary stress and financial hardship. Take the time to plan, model, and assess every aspect of your future retirement to ensure it's a happy and secure one.

Frequently Asked Questions

You can typically access funds from your IRA and 401(k) without the 10% early withdrawal penalty once you turn 59½. There is a specific exception known as the 'Rule of 55' for employer-sponsored plans if you leave your job at or after that age.

Since Medicare begins at age 65, you will need to find alternative health coverage for the six years in between. Options include COBRA, enrolling in a plan through the Affordable Care Act (ACA) marketplace, or potentially joining a spouse's employer-sponsored plan.

Yes, retiring at 59 and claiming Social Security as early as 62 will result in a permanently reduced monthly benefit. Delaying your claim past your full retirement age can increase your monthly payments.

The exact amount varies based on your anticipated expenses, lifestyle, and longevity. You'll need enough to cover all living costs, including healthcare premiums, until you reach ages when Social Security and Medicare are available, potentially requiring more savings than if you retired later.

The primary risks include running out of money due to a longer retirement period, underestimating healthcare costs before Medicare, and potential market downturns early in your retirement that deplete your savings.

Yes, it is always possible to return to work, either part-time or full-time. This can be an effective way to supplement your income, reduce withdrawals from savings, and maintain social engagement. Many early retirees explore consulting or other flexible work arrangements.

The Rule of 55 allows employees who leave their job at or after age 55 to take penalty-free withdrawals from that employer's 401(k) or 403(b) plan. Since 59 is after 55, this rule would apply to your most recent employer-sponsored retirement account, but not to IRAs.

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare provider regarding personal health decisions.