Skip to content

Is Humana a good prescription drug plan for seniors? A comprehensive review

3 min read

According to a 2025 review by NerdWallet, Humana's Medicare Part D plans boast higher-than-average government ratings for member experience. Choosing the right coverage is crucial, and evaluating if Is Humana a good prescription drug plan for seniors depends largely on your specific needs, budget, and medication list.

Quick Summary

Humana offers several Medicare Part D options with varying premiums and coverage, featuring competitive satisfaction ratings and potential savings on generics. Deciding if it is a good fit requires a close look at its specific plans, drug formulary, and costs to see if they align with your healthcare needs and financial situation.

Key Points

  • CMS Star Ratings: Humana's Medicare Part D plans received an above-average 3.49-star rating from CMS for 2025, indicating good overall quality and solid member experience.

  • Plan Tiers: Humana offers tiered plans—Value Rx, Basic Rx, and Premier Rx—to suit different budgets and coverage needs.

  • $0 Options: The Humana Value Rx plan provides a strong benefit with $0 copays and deductibles for Tier 1 and 2 drugs at preferred pharmacies.

  • Cost Considerations: While Humana's basic plans are affordable, its Premier Rx plan can have higher premiums than comparable plans from other carriers.

  • Formulary is Key: The plan's value depends on its formulary, or list of covered drugs; seniors must verify their specific medications are covered before enrolling.

  • Extra Help: Humana's Basic Rx plan is specifically designed to be beneficial for seniors who qualify for Medicare's Extra Help program.

In This Article

Humana's Medicare Part D plans: An overview

For 2025, Humana offers several stand-alone Medicare prescription drug plans (PDPs) across the U.S., including Humana Value Rx, Humana Basic Rx, and Humana Premier Rx, designed to meet different budgets and needs. Plan availability varies by location. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) Star Ratings provide insight into the quality of service and customer experience.

Analyzing CMS star ratings and customer satisfaction

Medicare Part D plans receive an annual rating from CMS on a 5-star scale. For 2025, Humana's Part D plans achieved an average rating of 3.49 stars, surpassing the overall average of 3.11 stars for stand-alone Part D plans. The rating is strong for member experience, indicating high member satisfaction.

Key Humana prescription drug plan options

Humana offers plans structured to cater to diverse needs. The Humana Value Rx plan is designed for seniors who primarily use low-cost generics, offering $0 copays and no deductible for drugs in Tiers 1 and 2 at preferred pharmacies. The Basic Rx option may suit individuals receiving Medicare Extra Help. The Premier Rx plan provides broader drug coverage and participates in the Senior Savings Model for select insulins.

Understanding drug costs and the formulary

Each Humana plan uses a formulary, a list of covered drugs divided into tiers, which influences your out-of-pocket costs. Lower tiers generally include more affordable generics. Your expenses are also affected by your coverage phase and using preferred network pharmacies. It's crucial to check if your medications are on the plan's formulary to assess its value.

Navigating coverage phases: The coverage gap

Humana's plans have coverage phases, including the initial stage and the coverage gap (donut hole). In 2025, the coverage gap starts after a certain spending threshold is met. During this phase, you typically pay up to 25% of the cost for both brand-name and generic drugs until you reach the catastrophic coverage phase.

Is Humana right for you? A comparison

To determine if Humana is a good fit, comparing its features to other providers is helpful. You can find detailed information using the official Medicare plan finder tool {Link: Medicare.gov https://www.medicare.gov/drug-plan-finder/}. A personalized evaluation of costs, coverage, and customer experience is key to deciding if Humana is the right prescription drug plan.

How to evaluate your options

  1. Check the formulary: Use the Medicare website's plan finder to confirm your medications are covered and compare costs.
  2. Compare costs: Look beyond the premium; evaluate deductibles, copayments, and coinsurance for your specific drugs and consider potential out-of-pocket costs throughout the year.
  3. Assess customer satisfaction: Review member experience ratings to gauge the ease of interacting with the company.
  4. Weigh plan options: Compare Humana's different plan tiers (Value, Basic, Premier) with similar offerings from other providers.
  5. Utilize pharmacy networks: Verify if your preferred pharmacy is in the plan's network to understand potential cost impacts.

Conclusion

Humana can be a strong choice for seniors, particularly for those who value high member satisfaction ratings and the potential generic drug savings from the Value Rx plan. The variety of plan options can suit different needs and budgets. However, Premier Rx premiums might be higher than competitors, and confirming your specific medications are on the formulary is essential for determining true value. A personalized evaluation of costs, coverage, and customer experience is key to deciding if Humana is the right prescription drug plan.

Frequently Asked Questions

For 2025, Humana's Medicare Part D plans have an average weighted star rating of 3.49 stars from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). This is higher than the average for all stand-alone Part D plans.

Yes, Humana offers the Value Rx plan, which is designed for seniors who value low-cost generics. It includes $0 copays and deductibles for Tier 1 and 2 drugs at preferred pharmacies.

Humana receives strong marks for member experience, scoring well above average on government ratings for member satisfaction. This suggests positive customer service and interactions.

Premiums for Humana's higher-end Premier Rx plan can be more expensive than those for comparable comprehensive plans offered by some competitors. It's important to compare costs directly with other carriers.

Yes, you must check if your specific medications are included on a Humana plan's formulary, or list of covered drugs, and determine your out-of-pocket costs before enrolling. This is essential for a complete picture of the plan's value.

The coverage gap is a phase where you pay a higher portion of your drug costs after you and your plan have spent a certain amount. With Humana, you will pay a percentage of the cost of drugs until you reach the catastrophic coverage phase.

To compare Humana with other plans, use the Medicare.gov plan finder tool. This allows you to enter your specific medications and compare premiums, deductibles, and formularies to find the best plan for you.

Yes, Humana's Premier Rx plan participates in the Senior Savings Model for insulin, which helps keep costs for certain insulins below a monthly cap.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare provider regarding personal health decisions.