Skip to content

What is the difference between hoist and lifter in aged care?

5 min read

With nearly 90% of residents in long-term care facilities experiencing some degree of limited mobility, patient transfer devices are essential for safety and dignity. This guide will detail exactly what is the difference between hoist and lifter in aged care to help you make an informed decision.

Quick Summary

While both assist patient transfers, hoists provide full-body support for individuals who are fully immobile. Lifters, conversely, typically assist those who can bear some weight, aiding a sit-to-stand movement and promoting independence.

Key Points

  • Hoist vs. Lifter Function: A hoist is for full-body lifting of immobile individuals, while a lifter assists in a sit-to-stand motion for those who can bear some weight.

  • Level of User Independence: Lifters promote active participation and help maintain muscle strength, whereas hoists are for passive transfers of fully dependent users.

  • Safety Depends on Assessment: Choosing the correct device is critical and requires a careful assessment of the user's weight-bearing ability to ensure safety for both the caregiver and the patient.

  • Training is Crucial: All caregivers must be properly trained on the specific equipment used to prevent injuries caused by misuse, equipment failure, or improper handling.

  • Ceiling Hoist vs. Mobile Lifter: Ceiling hoists save floor space and offer continuous travel, while mobile lifters are more compact and maneuverable for specific transfers like toileting.

In This Article

Understanding Aged Care Hoists

In aged care, the term 'hoist' typically refers to a full-body patient lift, also commonly known as a Hoyer lift. These devices are designed to provide maximum support for individuals who have very limited mobility or are completely dependent on a caregiver for transfers. Hoists are used for transferring a person who is unable to bear their own weight at all.

Key Characteristics of Hoists

Hoists operate using a sling system that fully cradles and supports the person's body. The lifting mechanism is either manual (hydraulic) or powered (electric), minimizing the physical strain on the caregiver. They are essential for a wide range of tasks, from moving a person from a bed to a wheelchair, repositioning someone in bed to prevent pressure sores, to assisting with bathing and toileting.

Types of Hoists in Aged Care

Mobile Hoists

  • Portable and Versatile: These are the most common type of hoist, featuring a wheeled base that allows them to be moved from room to room. The base often has adjustable legs that can be widened to fit around furniture like beds, chairs, and toilets.
  • Space Requirements: While they offer flexibility, mobile hoists require clear floor space to operate safely.
  • Power Source: Available in both manual hydraulic and electric models.

Ceiling Hoists

  • Overhead Track System: These are permanent fixtures, installed on an overhead track that runs along the ceiling.
  • Maximum Space: Ceiling hoists free up floor space, which can be a major advantage in smaller rooms.
  • Continuous Movement: The track system allows for smooth, continuous movement from one area to another without needing to navigate floor obstacles.

Understanding Aged Care Lifters

The term 'lifter' is often used more generally but in the context of mobility, it most often refers to a 'sit-to-stand' lift. This type of device is for individuals who have some weight-bearing capability but need assistance to transition from a seated position to a standing position. These devices promote active participation and help maintain a user's muscle strength.

Key Characteristics of Lifters

Lifters use a sling that supports the upper back and torso, with a secure platform and knee pads for the user to push up from. The device raises the person from a seated to a standing or semi-standing position, enabling a caregiver to assist with tasks like moving to the toilet or a different chair. It is crucial that the user can bear at least some of their own weight for a lifter to be used safely.

Types of Lifters in Aged Care

Sit-to-Stand Lifters

  • Active User Participation: These devices require the user to engage their leg and arm muscles to some extent during the transfer.
  • Promotes Independence: By supporting a partial weight-bearing movement, sit-to-stand lifters can help users maintain physical capability and dignity.
  • Ideal for Toileting: The design of sit-to-stand lifters is particularly beneficial for toileting, as it allows clothing to be adjusted easily while the user is supported.

Transfer Chairs

  • Integrated Mobility: A transfer chair is a type of lifter that combines a seat with a lifting mechanism, allowing a person to be transferred between a bed and other surfaces without a cumbersome sling.
  • Less Training Required: Some models require less caregiver training to operate than traditional hoists, reducing the risk of human error.

Comparison: Hoist vs. Lifter

Choosing between a hoist and a lifter depends entirely on the person's mobility level, their weight-bearing ability, and the specific transfer needs.

Feature Hoist (Full-Body) Lifter (Sit-to-Stand)
User Mobility Minimal or no weight-bearing capability. Full dependency. Partial weight-bearing capability. Can participate in the transfer.
Function Lifts and transfers the entire body, from fully reclined to seated position. Assists in transitioning from a sitting to a standing or semi-standing position.
Sling Type Full-body sling that cradles the user securely. Upper-body sling or padded harness combined with knee pads.
Primary Use Bed-to-chair transfers, repositioning, bathing, full lifts from the floor. Transfers for toileting, moving between seated positions, rehabilitation.
Caregiver Effort Minimal physical effort required, relies on hydraulic or electric power. Reduced physical effort, but requires user cooperation and stability.
Dignity & Independence Ensures safe transfers for immobile users but can feel more passive. Encourages active participation, promoting a greater sense of independence.
Maneuverability Mobile hoists can be bulky; ceiling hoists offer track-based movement. Generally more maneuverable in smaller spaces due to more compact design.

Making the Right Choice

Before selecting either a hoist or a lifter, a thorough assessment is essential. This evaluation should involve the user's mobility, strength, weight, and the physical space where the equipment will be used.

When to Choose a Hoist:

  • Full Dependence: When the person cannot bear any weight and requires full support for all transfers.
  • Floor Lifts: If there is a risk of falls and the person needs to be lifted from the floor safely.
  • Consistent Transfers: For frequent transfers that require minimal caregiver physical strain.

When to Choose a Lifter:

  • Partial Independence: When the person can partially bear their own weight but needs assistance standing.
  • Rehabilitation: To encourage and maintain existing mobility and muscle strength.
  • Targeted Transfers: Specifically for transfers to the toilet or other seated surfaces where user participation is possible.

Safety and Training Considerations

Regardless of the device chosen, proper training is non-negotiable. Caregivers must be adequately trained on the specific equipment to ensure safe and effective use, thereby protecting both the person being transferred and themselves from injury.

  1. Risk Assessment: Always conduct a risk assessment before each transfer to account for any changes in the user's condition or environment.
  2. Equipment Inspection: Regularly inspect the hoist, lifter, and especially the sling for signs of wear and tear, and follow manufacturer maintenance schedules.
  3. Communication: Communicate clearly with the person throughout the transfer process to ensure they are comfortable and cooperative.

For more detailed guidance on safe patient handling, visit the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) website, which provides comprehensive information and resources on the topic. OSHA Safe Patient Handling

Conclusion

The difference between a hoist and a lifter is based fundamentally on the user's level of mobility and need for support. A hoist provides full-body lifting for completely dependent individuals, while a lifter assists partially mobile users in a sit-to-stand motion. By understanding these distinctions, caregivers can select the appropriate equipment to ensure safe, dignified, and effective transfers in an aged care setting.

Frequently Asked Questions

A Hoyer lift is a brand name for a full-body hoist. It is used to transfer a person who is fully dependent and cannot bear any weight, using a sling system for complete support.

While some mobile hoists can be operated by a single person for simple transfers, many complex or heavy-duty transfers require two caregivers. A risk assessment should always be performed to determine the staffing needs, with safety being the highest priority.

Yes, sit-to-stand lifters are generally better for promoting independence as they require the user to participate in the transfer. By using their leg and arm muscles, individuals can maintain strength and mobility longer.

Weight capacity varies by specific model for both hoists and lifters. It is essential to check the Safe Working Load (SWL) for both the device and the sling before use, and never exceed this limit.

The primary deciding factor is the person's weight-bearing ability. If they can bear some weight, a lifter may be appropriate. If they are unable to bear any weight, a full-body hoist is the correct choice for a safe transfer.

No, a standard sit-to-stand lifter is not designed for floor lifts. This task requires a specific type of mobile or ceiling hoist with a full-body sling that can safely lift a person from the floor.

Risks include injury from equipment malfunction, improper use, using the wrong sling, or exceeding weight limits. Regular maintenance, proper training, and careful assessment before each use are crucial to mitigate these risks.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare provider regarding personal health decisions.