Skip to content

Do humans smell worse as they age? The science behind nonenal

6 min read

A 2001 study published in the Journal of Investigative Dermatology first isolated the chemical compound 2-nonenal, which is linked to a distinctive and sometimes musty body odor associated with aging. This odor is a result of natural physiological changes and isn't necessarily worse than other life-stage scents, but it is different, and it's a common factor when asking, 'Do humans smell worse as they age?'.

Quick Summary

As people age, body odor changes due to physiological factors like hormonal shifts and the increase of an oxidized compound called 2-nonenal. This odor is distinct but not inherently worse than other life-stage scents, though perception can vary. Nonenal is oil-based and not easily removed by regular soap. Strategies like using specialized washes, maintaining a healthy lifestyle, and proper clothing care can help manage age-related odor.

Key Points

  • 2-Nonenal is the culprit: Age-related body odor is caused by an oxidized fatty acid compound called 2-nonenal, which is a natural byproduct of aging skin.

  • It's not about poor hygiene: Nonenal is oil-based and not easily washed away by normal soap, so it is not a direct result of poor personal hygiene.

  • Perception is subjective: Studies show that the odor of older people is not necessarily perceived as unpleasant, and negative perceptions may be influenced by societal biases.

  • Specialized products can help: Using soaps with nonenal-neutralizing ingredients, like Japanese persimmon extract, can be more effective than standard cleansers.

  • Lifestyle impacts odor: A diet rich in antioxidants, staying hydrated, and managing stress can help reduce oxidative stress and lessen the odor.

  • Odor clings to fabrics: Nonenal can be absorbed by clothes and bedding, requiring special laundering techniques like using odor-eliminating detergents or vinegar in the wash.

In This Article

The chemistry of age-related body odor

Contrary to popular belief, the distinct scent often associated with older individuals is not a result of poor hygiene. Instead, it stems from specific chemical changes within the body that begin around middle age. A landmark 2001 study in Japan first identified the primary culprit as 2-nonenal, an unsaturated aldehyde. This compound is produced when omega-7 unsaturated fatty acids on the skin's surface undergo oxidative degradation. As skin's natural antioxidant defenses decline with age, this process increases, leading to higher levels of 2-nonenal.

Unlike sweat-related odors, which are caused by bacteria breaking down compounds in sweat, 2-nonenal is a product of skin lipid oxidation. Its unique nature means it is not water-soluble and, therefore, does not wash away easily with standard soap and water. This is a key reason the scent can be so persistent on skin, clothes, and bedding.

Other physiological changes contributing to odor

While 2-nonenal is the most-studied factor, other age-related changes also contribute to shifts in body odor:

  • Hormonal shifts: As women enter menopause, decreasing estrogen levels can alter sweat production and skin pH, resulting in a more noticeable body odor. Hormonal fluctuations at various life stages, including puberty, also cause distinct changes in scent.
  • Skin microbiome changes: The types of bacteria that live on our skin change throughout our lives. The interaction between these new bacterial populations and the different skin secretions produced with age can influence overall body scent.
  • Chronic health conditions: Certain diseases, such as diabetes, kidney disease, or liver problems, can alter body chemistry and produce noticeable changes in odor. Any sudden or unusual change in body scent should be discussed with a doctor to rule out underlying medical issues.

The psychology of scent perception

It is also important to consider how body odor is perceived, as a 2012 study published in PLOS ONE demonstrated. Researchers found that while people could reliably distinguish the scent of older individuals, they did not rate it as more unpleasant. In fact, younger subjects rated the odor of middle-aged men as the most unpleasant. The study suggested that negative perceptions of 'old person smell' might be influenced more by societal biases and associations with illness or nursing homes rather than the scent itself. Our sense of smell also diminishes with age, meaning older individuals may not notice the changes in their own body odor.

Managing age-related body odor

Managing nonenal requires more targeted methods than simply showering more frequently. The oil-based compound needs specific strategies for removal from the skin and personal items.

A Comparison of Nonenal Management Strategies Strategy Description Key Advantage Notes
Specialized Soaps Use of soaps formulated to neutralize nonenal, often containing ingredients like Japanese persimmon extract or acidified cleansers. Directly targets and breaks down the nonenal compound. Traditional soaps may not be effective due to nonenal's oil-based nature.
Healthy Lifestyle A diet rich in antioxidants (fruits, vegetables), staying hydrated, regular exercise, and stress management. Combats the oxidative stress that creates nonenal internally. Supports overall health and has broader wellness benefits beyond managing odor.
Clothing and Bedding Care Use of odor-eliminating laundry detergents, adding vinegar to the wash, and drying clothes in the sun. Removes stubborn nonenal residue that clings to fabrics. Nonenal can accumulate and concentrate in fabrics over time.
Improved Air Quality Regular ventilation, using air purifiers, and placing odor absorbers like baking soda in living spaces. Helps clear lingering odors from the environment. Addresses odors in the home that accumulate from clothing and furniture.
Professional Medical Advice Consulting a doctor if there is a sudden, significant change in odor. Can help rule out underlying health issues, such as diabetes or infections. Recommended for unusual or intense changes in body odor.

Conclusion: The complexity of age and odor

Ultimately, the question of whether humans smell worse as they age is more complex than a simple yes or no. The scent does change, a process driven by a compound called 2-nonenal, which is a normal byproduct of lipid oxidation in aging skin. Other contributing factors include hormonal shifts, medications, and changes in the skin's bacterial composition. While often perceived negatively, research suggests that the scent itself is not inherently unpleasant, and that societal biases can influence perception. By understanding the science behind nonenal and implementing targeted hygiene and lifestyle practices, individuals can effectively manage age-related body odor and address any concerns with confidence. The key is to recognize it as a natural part of the aging process and use appropriate methods for care.

Key takeaways

  • Nonenal is the cause: The distinct "old person smell" is largely caused by 2-nonenal, a compound produced from the oxidation of fatty acids in aging skin.
  • Not a hygiene issue: Nonenal is oil-based and not easily removed by standard soap, so it is not a result of poor hygiene.
  • Smell perception varies: Studies show that while older adults have a distinct scent, it is often rated as less intense and not necessarily unpleasant, suggesting that social biases may influence perception.
  • Targeted cleaning is key: Managing nonenal requires specialized soaps or ingredients like Japanese persimmon extract that can break down the oil-based compound effectively.
  • Lifestyle plays a role: A diet rich in antioxidants, staying hydrated, and regular exercise can help mitigate the oxidative stress that contributes to nonenal production.
  • Odor clings to fabrics: Nonenal can accumulate on clothes and bedding, so using odor-eliminating laundry products and airing out items can help.

FAQs

Q: What is 2-nonenal? A: 2-nonenal is a naturally occurring chemical compound and unsaturated aldehyde that is produced when omega-7 fatty acids on the skin oxidize due to the aging process. It is primarily responsible for the distinctive, sometimes musty, odor associated with older age.

Q: Why doesn't regular soap remove age-related odor? A: Regular soaps are water-based and effective at washing away sweat and bacteria. However, 2-nonenal is an oil-based compound and is not water-soluble, meaning it resists removal with standard cleansing methods. Specialized soaps with targeted ingredients are needed to break it down.

Q: At what age does nonenal production begin? A: Research indicates that 2-nonenal begins to appear in body odor around the age of 40 and tends to increase with age. Hormonal changes and a decline in the skin's natural antioxidants are contributing factors.

Q: Can dietary changes help with age-related body odor? A: Yes, diet can play a significant role. A diet rich in antioxidant-heavy foods, such as fruits and vegetables, can help combat the oxidative stress that produces nonenal. Staying well-hydrated can also help flush toxins from the body.

Q: What is the emotional impact of age-related body odor? A: For many older adults, dealing with nonenal odor can lead to feelings of self-consciousness or embarrassment. However, taking proactive steps to manage the odor through targeted skincare and lifestyle changes can help restore confidence.

Q: Is a sudden change in body odor a sign of a medical problem? A: While a gradual change in body odor is a normal part of aging, a sudden or intense shift could indicate an underlying health issue, such as diabetes or kidney disease. If you notice a significant or abrupt change, it is wise to consult a healthcare provider.

Q: Are there any specific laundry tips for removing nonenal from clothing? A: Since nonenal clings to fabrics, use odor-eliminating detergents, add half a cup of white vinegar to the rinse cycle, and air dry clothes in sunlight whenever possible, as UV rays help kill odor-causing bacteria.

Citations

Frequently Asked Questions

2-nonenal is a naturally occurring chemical compound and unsaturated aldehyde that is produced when omega-7 fatty acids on the skin oxidize due to the aging process. It is primarily responsible for the distinctive, sometimes musty, odor associated with older age.

Regular soaps are water-based and effective at washing away sweat and bacteria. However, 2-nonenal is an oil-based compound and is not water-soluble, meaning it resists removal with standard cleansing methods. Specialized soaps with targeted ingredients are needed to break it down.

Research indicates that 2-nonenal begins to appear in body odor around the age of 40 and tends to increase with age. Hormonal changes and a decline in the skin's natural antioxidants are contributing factors.

Yes, diet can play a significant role. A diet rich in antioxidant-heavy foods, such as fruits and vegetables, can help combat the oxidative stress that produces nonenal. Staying well-hydrated can also help flush toxins from the body.

For many older adults, dealing with nonenal odor can lead to feelings of self-consciousness or embarrassment. However, taking proactive steps to manage the odor through targeted skincare and lifestyle changes can help restore confidence.

While a gradual change in body odor is a normal part of aging, a sudden or intense shift could indicate an underlying health issue, such as diabetes or kidney disease. If you notice a significant or abrupt change, it is wise to consult a healthcare provider.

Since nonenal clings to fabrics, use odor-eliminating detergents, add half a cup of white vinegar to the rinse cycle, and air dry clothes in sunlight whenever possible, as UV rays help kill odor-causing bacteria.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare provider regarding personal health decisions.