Skip to content

Is it wise to take spousal Social Security benefits?

4 min read

According to the Social Security Administration, millions of Americans currently receive a spousal benefit. For many couples, this benefit can significantly enhance retirement income, but the decision to claim is complex. A careful evaluation is crucial to determine if it is wise to take spousal Social Security benefits, as the decision has significant long-term financial implications for you and your partner.

Quick Summary

Claiming spousal Social Security benefits can be a strategic move to boost retirement income, but its wisdom depends heavily on individual circumstances like age, earnings history, and your spouse's claiming status. You must understand the complex rules to maximize your payout and avoid costly mistakes.

Key Points

  • Claiming Strategy: The wisdom of taking spousal benefits depends on your age, your work record, and your spouse's claiming decisions.

  • Timing Is Key: Claiming spousal benefits before your full retirement age results in a permanent reduction, while waiting until FRA yields the maximum 50% payout.

  • Deemed Filing: For those turning 62 after 2015, the 'deemed filing' rule means you cannot take just spousal benefits; you will be paid the higher of your own or your spousal benefit.

  • Survivor Benefits: A critical component of the decision is how it impacts survivor benefits for the lower-earning spouse, which can be maximized if the higher earner delays their claim.

  • Divorce Implications: Even after divorce, you might be eligible for spousal benefits based on an ex-spouse's record, provided the marriage lasted at least 10 years.

  • Holistic View: The best choice is part of an overall financial plan, taking into account retirement savings, life expectancy, and need for current income.

In This Article

Understanding Social Security Spousal Benefits

Spousal Social Security benefits are designed for individuals who have limited or no Social Security earnings on their own. This benefit allows a spouse to claim up to 50% of the working spouse's Primary Insurance Amount (PIA) at their own full retirement age (FRA). However, eligibility and calculation are not straightforward and require careful planning.

Who Is Eligible for Spousal Benefits?

Eligibility for spousal benefits depends on a few key factors:

  • Age: You must be at least 62 years old to claim early, or at your FRA to claim the full amount.
  • Marital Status: You must be legally married to someone who is entitled to their own Social Security retirement or disability benefits. The working spouse must have already filed for their benefits for you to claim spousal benefits (unless you are a caregiver for a qualifying child).
  • Relationship to Primary Earner: If you have your own work history, you must be entitled to a smaller benefit based on your own earnings record than you would be entitled to as a spouse. The Social Security Administration (SSA) will always pay your own benefit first. If the spousal benefit is higher, you'll receive a combination of both to equal the higher amount.

The Importance of Timing: Claiming Early vs. Waiting

The decision of when to start collecting benefits is one of the most critical you will make. Claiming early comes with a permanent reduction in your monthly benefit. Waiting until your FRA ensures you receive the full 50% of your spouse's PIA. The table below compares the impact of claiming at different ages, assuming a full retirement age of 67.

Age of Claiming Spousal Benefit as % of PIA Impact on Monthly Benefit
62 ~35% Permanently Reduced
63 ~37.5% Permanently Reduced
64 ~41.7% Permanently Reduced
65 ~45.8% Permanently Reduced
67 (FRA) 50% Full Benefit

It's important to remember that for spousal benefits, there is no advantage to waiting past your own FRA. Unlike your own retirement benefit, spousal benefits do not earn delayed retirement credits after your FRA.

Navigating the Deemed Filing Rule

For those who reached age 62 after January 1, 2016, the deemed filing rule significantly affects claiming strategies. This rule means that if you file for either your own retirement benefit or your spousal benefit, you are automatically "deemed" to have filed for the other. The SSA will pay you the higher of the two benefit amounts, but you cannot choose to collect only one. This eliminates some of the strategic claiming options, like the "file and suspend" strategy, that were previously available.

Factors to Consider Before You Decide

Making a wise choice about spousal benefits requires evaluating several key factors unique to your situation. What's right for one couple may be detrimental to another.

Earnings and Financial Health

  • Benefit Comparison: If your own earned benefit is much smaller than your potential spousal benefit, claiming the spousal benefit may be a straightforward choice. If they are close, you'll need to weigh the monthly difference against the long-term impact.
  • Retirement Savings: Consider your overall retirement picture. If you have substantial savings and can afford to delay benefits, waiting until FRA is often a more profitable strategy.
  • Need for Income Now: If immediate income is a necessity, claiming early may be the right decision despite the reduction.

Health and Life Expectancy

  • Your Life Expectancy: If you have a family history of longevity, waiting for a higher monthly payout may make sense. However, if your life expectancy is shorter, claiming earlier could provide a greater total lifetime payout.
  • Your Spouse's Life Expectancy: This is especially critical for survivor benefits. If you are the lower earner, delaying your spouse's claiming until age 70 maximizes their monthly benefit, which in turn maximizes the survivor benefit you could potentially receive. A spouse can receive 100% of the deceased worker's benefit as a survivor.

Coordinating with Your Spouse's Claiming Strategy

Your decision is not made in a vacuum; it's part of a coordinated strategy with your spouse. The timing of both spouses' claims impacts the total household retirement income. For instance, the higher earner delaying their benefit until age 70 not only increases their own payout but also enhances the survivor benefit for the lower-earning spouse. This is often one of the most powerful reasons for a higher earner to delay their claim.

For more detailed information on Social Security claiming strategies, consider reviewing resources on the official Social Security Administration blog. For example, their guide on Do You Qualify for Social Security Spouse's Benefits? can be an excellent starting point.

The Impact of Divorce on Spousal Benefits

Even after a divorce, you may still be eligible for spousal benefits based on your ex-spouse's record. This is a complex area with specific rules:

  • Your marriage must have lasted at least 10 years.
  • You must be unmarried at the time of your claim.
  • You must be at least 62 years old.
  • Your ex-spouse must be eligible for Social Security retirement or disability benefits, but does not need to have filed. If your ex-spouse has not yet filed, you can claim benefits if you have been divorced for at least two years.

Making the Final Decision

Ultimately, whether it's wise to take spousal Social Security benefits depends on a holistic view of your finances, health, and family situation. For some, it is a crucial lifeline; for others, it is a strategic tool to optimize total household benefits. The deemed filing rule has simplified some aspects, but the core choice of when to claim remains a significant one. Consult with a financial advisor and utilize the tools on the SSA website to model different scenarios before making your final decision.

Frequently Asked Questions

A spousal benefit is calculated as a percentage of your spouse's Primary Insurance Amount (PIA). The maximum is 50% if you claim at your full retirement age. This percentage is reduced if you claim early, but does not increase if you delay past your FRA.

Yes, if you have been married to a qualified worker for at least one year and are at least 62, you can receive spousal benefits. If you care for a qualifying child, you may be eligible regardless of age.

No, claiming a spousal benefit has no impact on the working spouse's retirement benefit amount. The benefits are calculated and paid separately.

The SSA will first pay you the benefit based on your own earnings record. If the spousal benefit is higher, you will receive an additional amount to bring you up to the spousal benefit level. You receive the higher of the two, not both.

The SSA automatically gives you the higher of the two benefits, thanks to the deemed filing rule. The wise decision is to understand your options regarding when to claim to maximize your total lifetime payout, especially considering survivor benefits.

Under the deemed filing rule, you automatically get the higher of the two benefits when you file. If your own benefit increases due to delayed retirement credits after you start receiving a spousal benefit, you will be switched to the higher amount. However, this is only an option for those who turned 62 before 2016.

Survivor benefits are a different category, allowing you to collect up to 100% of your deceased spouse's benefit. For this reason, delaying the higher earner's claim can be a powerful strategy for ensuring a larger survivor benefit for the lower-earning spouse.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare provider regarding personal health decisions.