Why Are Standard Flu Shots Less Effective for Seniors?
As individuals age, their immune system undergoes a process called immunosenescence, which makes it less responsive to pathogens and vaccines. This natural decline means a standard-dose flu vaccine, which works effectively for younger adults, may not provide the same level of robust protection for a 70-year-old. Since older adults are at a significantly higher risk for serious complications from the flu, including pneumonia and other respiratory issues, better options are required. The flu is not just a nuisance for this demographic; it can be life-threatening.
To counter this age-related immunity challenge, pharmaceutical companies and public health organizations developed enhanced flu vaccines designed specifically for older adults. These specialized vaccines contain either a higher dose of the antigen or an immune-boosting adjuvant to prompt a stronger and more effective immune response. The CDC officially recommends these enhanced vaccines for people aged 65 and older.
The Three Recommended Flu Shots for Seniors
For individuals aged 65 and older, the CDC and the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) preferentially recommend three specific types of influenza vaccines over standard-dose, unadjuvanted flu shots. There is no stated preference among these three enhanced options, so the choice often comes down to availability and any specific health considerations you may have.
-
High-Dose Quadrivalent Flu Vaccine (Fluzone High-Dose): This vaccine contains four times the amount of antigen—the part of the vaccine that triggers an immune response—as a standard flu shot. This increased dose is designed to provide a more powerful immune response and therefore greater protection. Clinical trials have shown it to be more effective in preventing the flu in older adults compared to a standard-dose vaccine.
-
Adjuvanted Quadrivalent Flu Vaccine (Fluad Quadrivalent): This vaccine includes an adjuvant, an ingredient that enhances the body’s immune response to the vaccine. The adjuvant, MF59, works by creating a larger, more robust immune reaction without increasing the amount of antigen. Studies have indicated that the adjuvanted vaccine can be particularly effective in preventing flu-related hospitalizations and pneumonia in older adults.
-
Recombinant Quadrivalent Flu Vaccine (Flublok Quadrivalent): This vaccine is manufactured using a different process that does not use chicken eggs and creates a potent, recombinant antigen. It is approved for adults aged 18 and older, but provides a stronger immune response that is particularly beneficial for seniors. It is also a good option for individuals with severe, life-threatening egg allergies, though most egg-based vaccines are safe for those with less severe allergies.
Comparison of Flu Shot Options for a 70-Year-Old
Choosing the best option involves weighing the benefits and potential side effects. While the CDC doesn't prefer one enhanced vaccine over another, comparing their features can help inform your discussion with a healthcare provider.
| Feature | High-Dose Vaccine (Fluzone HD) | Adjuvanted Vaccine (Fluad) | Recombinant Vaccine (Flublok) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mechanism | Contains 4x the antigen of a standard shot to boost immune response. | Includes an immune-boosting adjuvant to provoke a stronger response. | Utilizes a non-egg-based method to produce a potent, recombinant antigen. |
| Effectiveness (Seniors) | Shown to be more effective than standard doses at preventing flu illness and hospitalizations. | More effective than standard doses at preventing flu and flu-related hospitalizations, potentially providing longer protection. | Also provides a strong immune response, proven to be more effective in adults over 50 than standard shots. |
| Manufacturing Process | Egg-based, though typically safe for those with mild egg allergies. | Egg-based, but also safe for most with egg allergies. | Egg-free, making it a reliable choice for individuals with a severe egg allergy. |
| Common Side Effects | Mild side effects may be slightly more frequent than with standard shots, including pain, muscle aches, and headache. | Mild to moderate side effects may occur, including pain, redness, and headache. | Similar mild side effects to other shots, such as injection site pain and headache. |
| Availability | Widely available and often prioritized for the 65+ age group. | Also widely available but distribution can vary by clinic or pharmacy. | Readily available and recommended for seniors and others 18+. |
What if an Enhanced Vaccine Isn't Available?
While the enhanced vaccines are the preferential choice, the most important thing is to get vaccinated. If for any reason a high-dose, adjuvanted, or recombinant vaccine is not available at your healthcare provider or pharmacy, you should still get a standard-dose flu shot. Any flu vaccine is better than no flu vaccine, especially for older adults who face a higher risk of severe illness from influenza.
When to Get the Flu Shot
The timing of vaccination is important, especially for seniors. The CDC recommends that adults, particularly those aged 65 and older, get their flu vaccine in September or October. This timing helps ensure protection lasts throughout the peak of flu season, which typically occurs from December through February, without vaccinating so early (e.g., July or August) that immunity begins to wane before the season ends.
Conclusion
For a 70-year-old, the best flu shot is not a standard one but a specialized, high-potency vaccine recommended by the CDC. Options include the high-dose (Fluzone High-Dose), adjuvanted (Fluad Quadrivalent), or recombinant (Flublok Quadrivalent) vaccine, all of which are formulated to produce a stronger immune response in older adults. Discussing these options with your doctor or pharmacist can help you make the best choice based on your individual health profile and local availability. Regardless of the type, an annual flu shot remains the single best way to reduce the risk of serious complications from influenza. For more information, you can visit the CDC's page on Flu and People 65 Years and Older.
