Skip to content

Is Nordic walking better than walking for seniors? An expert analysis

5 min read

Nordic walking engages up to 90% of the body's muscles, turning a simple stroll into a comprehensive workout.

But is Nordic walking better than walking for seniors looking to improve their health, balance, and physical strength safely?

This in-depth guide examines the benefits and drawbacks of both activities to help you decide.

Quick Summary

Nordic walking is generally more beneficial than regular walking for seniors, offering superior full-body engagement, cardiovascular benefits, and improved stability through the use of poles.

Key Points

  • Full-Body Workout: Nordic walking engages up to 90% of your body's muscles, targeting both upper and lower body muscle groups for a more comprehensive workout than regular walking.

  • Superior Cardio: It elevates your heart rate more effectively than regular walking, providing a better cardiovascular workout without a higher feeling of exertion.

  • Enhanced Stability: The use of two poles provides four points of contact with the ground, significantly improving balance and reducing the risk of falls for seniors.

  • Reduced Joint Stress: Poles absorb some of the impact with each step, lessening the strain on sensitive joints like the knees and hips.

  • Higher Calorie Burn: Due to increased muscle engagement, Nordic walking can burn significantly more calories than traditional walking at the same pace.

  • Improved Posture: The technique promotes an upright posture, which helps with spinal alignment and can alleviate back and shoulder pain.

In This Article

Understanding the Fundamentals: What is Nordic Walking?

Originating in Finland as an off-season training method for cross-country skiers, Nordic walking uses specially designed poles to propel the body forward. Unlike hiking or using a cane for balance, Nordic walking involves a specific technique where the poles are used actively with the arm swing, in opposition to the leg stride. This coordinated movement engages muscles throughout the upper body, core, and lower body, making it a highly efficient exercise for older adults.

The Mechanics of a Full-Body Workout

While regular walking is an excellent low-impact exercise, its primary focus is on the lower body. Nordic walking, by contrast, transforms this movement into a comprehensive full-body workout. The active use of the poles engages muscles in the chest, shoulders, triceps, and upper back. This increased muscular involvement leads to a higher calorie burn and improved muscle tone throughout the entire body, which is particularly important for combating age-related muscle loss.

Core Benefits of Nordic Walking for Seniors

Enhanced Cardiovascular Health

By engaging a larger muscle mass, Nordic walking elevates the heart rate more effectively than conventional walking, providing a superior cardiovascular workout without feeling more strenuous. Studies show it can boost cardiorespiratory fitness and increase aerobic capacity. This is especially beneficial for older adults managing conditions like heart disease or high blood pressure, who can achieve a higher intensity workout while still enjoying a low-impact activity.

Improved Balance and Stability

For many seniors, a key concern is the risk of falls. Nordic walking provides four points of contact with the ground instead of two, significantly improving stability. The poles offer a sense of security on uneven terrain and help correct a shuffling gait, promoting a more upright and symmetrical posture. This enhanced balance and confidence can encourage older adults to stay active outdoors for longer, reducing anxiety and promoting a more independent lifestyle.

Reduced Joint Strain

Regular walking places all the impact on the lower body joints—hips, knees, and ankles. The poles in Nordic walking help redistribute this weight and impact force, absorbing some of the shock with each step. This makes Nordic walking an excellent option for seniors with arthritis or joint pain, or those recovering from injuries, as it can allow them to walk faster and for longer distances with less discomfort. Research indicates that the use of poles can reduce pressure on the lower body, making it a gentler cardio exercise.

Mental and Social Well-being

Like other forms of exercise, Nordic walking promotes the release of feel-good hormones, combating symptoms of depression and anxiety. It also offers a great opportunity for social connection. Many communities offer guided Nordic walking groups, which provide a chance to connect with peers, share experiences, and receive mutual encouragement. This social aspect is crucial for preventing feelings of loneliness and isolation, contributing to a better overall quality of life.

Nordic Walking vs. Regular Walking: A Comparative Look

Feature Nordic Walking Regular Walking
Muscles Engaged Up to 90% of the body's muscles (upper and lower) Around 50% of the body's muscles (mostly lower)
Calorie Burn Up to 46% higher Standard
Impact on Joints Lower impact, as poles absorb some shock Standard, all impact on lower body
Stability Four points of contact for enhanced balance Two points of contact
Cardio Intensity Higher intensity without higher perceived exertion Standard intensity
Equipment Needed Special Nordic walking poles None (comfortable shoes recommended)
Learning Curve Requires learning proper technique Instinctive and natural

Potential Drawbacks and Considerations

While the benefits are significant, there are some factors to consider before starting Nordic walking.

  • Technique is Key: Using the poles incorrectly can be ineffective or, worse, lead to injury. Incorrect form can cause back pain or strain on the wrists and shoulders. It is highly recommended to seek instruction from a certified trainer to learn the proper technique.
  • Existing Upper Body Injuries: Individuals with certain upper body conditions, such as arthritis in the hands or wrists, may find gripping the poles uncomfortable. Consultation with a doctor or physical therapist is advised.
  • Investment in Equipment: Unlike regular walking, Nordic walking requires an initial investment in a proper pair of poles. Quality adjustable poles with comfortable grips are essential.
  • Trip Hazard: Although poles enhance stability, focusing too much on pole placement can lead to a trip hazard, especially on technical trails. Paying attention to your footing remains crucial.

Getting Started with Nordic Walking

1. Consult a Healthcare Professional

Before beginning any new exercise routine, especially if you have underlying health conditions, consult your doctor. They can provide guidance and confirm that Nordic walking is a safe option for you.

2. Choose the Right Poles

When selecting poles, ensure they are the correct height. As a general rule, your elbow should be at a 90-degree angle when holding the pole with the tip on the ground. Adjustable poles are great for finding the perfect fit. Look for lightweight materials like aluminum or carbon fiber and comfortable, ergonomic handles with supportive straps.

3. Learn the Technique Properly

Consider taking a class or watching instructional videos from reputable sources. The basic movement involves walking with opposing arm and leg movements, using the poles to push off and propel yourself forward. A good technique will feel natural and rhythmic, similar to a cross-country skiing motion.

For more detailed guidance on technique, you can find helpful resources from health authorities. For instance, the Cleveland Clinic offers an excellent guide on Nordic walking Cleveland Clinic: Nordic Walking.

Conclusion: Making the Right Choice for Your Health

In summary, for many older adults, the answer to is Nordic walking better than walking for seniors is a resounding yes. It provides a more complete, full-body workout that burns more calories and offers superior cardiovascular benefits compared to regular walking. The added stability and reduced joint stress are significant advantages, especially for those with concerns about balance or joint pain. While regular walking remains a fantastic exercise, Nordic walking adds an extra layer of health benefits. By learning the correct technique and investing in the right equipment, seniors can elevate their fitness routine and enjoy a more dynamic, safe, and engaging way to stay active.

Frequently Asked Questions

No, the basic technique for Nordic walking is relatively easy to learn. It builds on the natural rhythm of walking but requires using poles correctly. Taking a class or watching instructional videos can quickly help you master the proper form.

Yes, Nordic walking poles are excellent for improving balance and stability. By providing two extra points of contact with the ground, they offer increased support and confidence, especially on uneven or slippery surfaces, reducing the risk of falls.

With the correct technique, Nordic walking should not put undue stress on the shoulders or wrists. Proper form involves using the entire arm and core to propel the body, with the wrist strap assisting in the push-off. Those with pre-existing injuries should still consult a doctor.

Yes, Nordic walking can be very effective for weight management. Because it engages more muscles and increases calorie expenditure by up to 46% compared to regular walking, it offers a more efficient way for seniors to burn calories and lose weight.

Nordic walking can be a great option for seniors with arthritis. The poles help distribute weight, which reduces the load on weight-bearing joints like the knees and hips. However, it is essential to consult a doctor, especially for arthritis affecting the hands.

For beginners, adjustable aluminum poles are often a good choice. They are durable and allow you to find the correct height. Look for comfortable cork or foam handles and supportive straps that fit your hands well.

Consistency is key. A good goal is to aim for two to three sessions per week, lasting 30–45 minutes each. This will provide noticeable improvements in cardiovascular health, strength, and balance over time.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare provider regarding personal health decisions.