Skip to content

Is walking with a cane good for you? The benefits and risks

4 min read

According to research, most people who have had a fall at home did not use an assistive device, even though a cane can help prevent falls. Used correctly, a cane offers immense benefits for mobility and independence, but many wonder if walking with a cane is good for you and when it's appropriate.

Quick Summary

Walking with a cane offers significant benefits, including improved stability, reduced joint strain, and enhanced confidence, especially when used correctly for mild to moderate mobility issues or during recovery from injury.

Key Points

  • Reduces joint stress: Canes help offload up to 25% of your body weight from painful joints like knees and hips.

  • Enhances stability: Providing a wider base of support, a cane reduces the risk of falls and improves balance, especially on uneven surfaces.

  • Improves posture: Using a properly fitted cane encourages an upright gait, preventing slouching and reducing back strain over time.

  • Boosts independence: By increasing confidence in mobility, a cane can help individuals maintain their social life and daily activities.

  • Requires correct technique: Holding the cane in the hand opposite the weak leg is crucial for maximizing support and safety.

  • Not for heavy reliance: If you need to bear more than 25% of your weight, a walker may be a safer and more stable option.

In This Article

The Many Benefits of Walking with a Cane

Contrary to a common stigma, using a walking cane is a proactive step toward maintaining an active and independent lifestyle. A properly fitted cane provides more than just physical support; it can be a tool for empowerment and safety.

Relieves Joint Pressure and Reduces Pain

A cane is particularly effective at redistributing your body weight, which takes a significant load off painful or injured joints, such as the knees, hips, and ankles. This reduction in impact and stress can lead to greater comfort during walking or standing, especially for those with conditions like arthritis or those recovering from surgery.

Improves Posture and Spinal Alignment

When experiencing pain or instability, individuals often compensate by slouching or leaning, which can worsen spinal alignment over time. A properly sized cane encourages an upright posture, training the body to engage core and back muscles more effectively and preventing the development of back pain caused by poor gait.

Enhances Stability and Reduces Fall Risk

Falls are a leading cause of injury, but a cane provides a crucial third point of contact with the ground, creating a wider base of support. This significantly improves balance and minimizes the risk of slipping or tripping, both indoors and outdoors. A study found that elderly subjects showed higher balance scores when using a walking stick compared to not using one.

Reduces Fatigue and Boosts Endurance

For those with limited stamina or muscle weakness, a cane allows for a more efficient distribution of energy. This support helps conserve energy, allowing individuals to walk longer distances and engage more fully in daily activities without overexertion.

Builds Confidence and Independence

Dealing with mobility issues can lead to anxiety and social isolation. A cane provides peace of mind and restores a sense of freedom and autonomy, reducing the fear of falling. With increased confidence in their movements, individuals are more likely to stay socially active and engaged.

Choosing the Right Cane: A Comparison Table

Choosing the right cane is crucial for maximizing its benefits. Here is a comparison of common cane types to help guide your decision.

Cane Type Primary Function Ideal User Pros Cons
Standard (Single-Point) Basic balance and stability Mild balance issues, temporary support post-injury Lightweight, easy to maneuver, affordable Offers minimal stability compared to other options
Quad Cane (Four-Point) Enhanced stability and support Moderate balance issues, post-stroke recovery, unsteady gait Wider base of support, stands on its own Heavier, bulkier, can be difficult on stairs
Offset Cane Better weight distribution Individuals needing consistent weight-bearing support, arthritis Ergonomic grip, places weight directly over the shaft Bulky for travel, less aesthetic than traditional styles
Folding Cane Portability and convenience Individuals needing intermittent support, travelers Easily folds for storage and transport Folding mechanism can feel less sturdy

How to Use a Cane with Proper Technique

Even the right cane is only effective if used correctly. A physical therapist can provide the best guidance, but these are some general best practices:

  1. Hold the cane in the hand opposite your weak leg. This feels counterintuitive but is how the body's natural gait is replicated. If your right leg is weak, hold the cane in your left hand.
  2. Move the cane and your weaker leg forward at the same time. As they contact the ground, shift some weight through your cane before stepping forward with your stronger leg.
  3. Ensure a proper fit. The cane handle should be level with the crease of your wrist when your arm is hanging straight at your side. Your elbow should have a 15–20 degree bend when gripping the handle.
  4. Maintain upright posture. Avoid leaning over the cane. Keep your back straight and look forward as you walk.
  5. Use correct form on stairs. When going up, lead with your strong leg first. When going down, lead with your weak leg and the cane simultaneously. An easy mnemonic: “Up with the good, down with the bad.”

Risks of Improper Cane Usage

Failing to use a cane correctly can negate its benefits and introduce new problems. Incorrect height, for instance, can force you to lean, causing back, neck, and shoulder strain. Holding the cane on the wrong side can also throw off your balance and increase fall risk. It's also important to use the cane for support during walking, not as the primary tool for standing up or sitting down, which can be unstable.

Maintaining Your Cane for Safety

Regular maintenance is a simple but vital step for safety. Always check the rubber tip at the bottom of the cane for wear and tear, as a slick or worn tip can increase the risk of slipping. Replacement tips are inexpensive and widely available. Furthermore, keep floors and pathways clear of hazards like throw rugs, cords, and spills to prevent trips and falls.

Conclusion: Making an Informed Choice

Deciding to use a cane is a personal health choice that should be made in consultation with a healthcare professional, such as a doctor or physical therapist. If used correctly, a cane can significantly improve your quality of life by providing stability, reducing pain, and boosting independence. The benefits of using a cane far outweigh the potential downsides, especially if proper technique is learned and practiced diligently.

For more detailed instructions on proper usage, consult an authority like Cleveland Clinic on How to Use a Cane.

Frequently Asked Questions

It is better to walk with a cane if you have mild to moderate mobility issues, as it can significantly improve your balance and reduce your risk of falling. For some, walking without support could increase strain and fatigue.

Using a cane on the wrong side can increase the load on your painful or weak joint, potentially causing more pain and an unbalanced gait. For example, if you have a sore right knee, the cane should be held in your left hand.

A cane primarily offers support rather than building leg strength directly. However, by providing stability and reducing pain, it can enable you to walk more frequently and for longer distances, indirectly helping maintain leg muscle tone.

You might need a cane if you experience mild balance issues, joint pain, muscle weakness, or are recovering from an injury. Consulting a physical therapist or doctor is recommended to assess your specific needs.

A cane can be used both temporarily, such as during recovery from surgery or an injury, and on a long-term basis for managing chronic conditions or age-related mobility issues.

For more significant balance issues, a quad cane (with four feet) or an offset cane (which centers weight) is generally better than a standard single-point cane because they offer a wider, more stable base of support.

While you do not need a prescription to buy most canes, it is highly recommended to consult a healthcare provider or physical therapist. They can ensure the cane is appropriate for your condition and help with proper fitting.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare provider regarding personal health decisions.